Contact Information
- 15800 Progress, Mora, MN, 55051
- info@preessays.com
- +1-786-220-3368
Browse our Free Essay examples and check out our Writing tools to get your assignments done.
Final Assignment
Assume you are an advisor to the mayor of a large city. The mayor considers air pollution to be a serious problem. The mayor heard that the Municipality of The Hague will be making a subsidy available for the purchase of electric cars for private individuals and companies. A concise description is presented below.
The
mayor wants to be advised from an economic point of view. You are requested to
write a policy brief on this topic (max. 2000 words).
1. An explanation of what type of
market failure, if any, is addressed by the subsidy.
2. An explanation of whether it
makes sense, from an economic point of view, to implement these measures at the
local level.
3. A discussion of whether the
subsidy can be expected to be welfare enhancing. Also discuss reasons why the
subsidy may fail to provide an efficient solution.
The
deadline for handing-in (uploading via Turnitin) is 3 July 2017, 9 AM.
The Municipality of The Hague will be making a subsidy available as of 1 July for the purchase of electric cars for private individuals and companies. The measures are meant to further stimulate electric transportation in the city. The municipality will provide a € 5,000 subsidy towards the purchase of a new car, van or taxi and € 3,000 towards the purchase of a used car. Electric transportation is good for the quality of the
air. For this reason there are various measures in the area of electric
transportation in The Hague. Examples include 500 charging stations
throughout the city, 5 new fast-charging stations and the promotion of
electric transportation in all kinds of ways.
Electric cars cost more than non-electric cars.
By subsidising part of the difference, the municipality would like to
encourage private individuals and businesses to drive electric vehicles.
Electric transportation is most interesting for people who drive a lot, such
as taxis. They recover the purchase price the fastest thanks to lower energy
costs per kilometre and lower costs for maintenance. |
|||
Conditions
|
|||
The most important conditions for qualifying for
the subsidy are: |
|||
|
|
The subsidy will be granted only to 100%
electric cars. Hybrid vehicles are not eligible. |
|
|
|
The applicant for the subsidy for an electric
vehicle must be living in The Hague in any case as of 1 January 2016. |
|
|
|
A company applying for a
subsidy must be located in The Hague in any case as of 1 January 2016. |
|
|
|
An applicant can get a subsidy for a maximum of
4 vehicles. |
|
Good to know:
|
The subsidy is a maximum of €
3,000 for a used car and a maximum of € 5,000 for a new car. |
|
The subsidy is never higher than 50% of the
purchase price. |
|
The total amount of subsidy available for
private cars is € 200,000. For delivery vans and taxis there is a total of €
400,000 available. |
|
The measures expire at the end of 2017 or
earlier if the subsidy has been used up.
|
Source: https://www.denhaag.nl/home/bewoners/to/New-Hague-subsidy-for-electric-cars.htm
Economic
Regulations: Subsidies on Electric Cars
Name
Institution/Affiliation
1.0
Introduction
Subsidies
refer to the act of the government paying part of the overall cost to the firm.
For that reason, the government gets to reduce the price of the targeted goods,
therefore resulting in increased consumption. Availability of subsidies in the
economy results in the shift of the supply curve to the right side. Thus,
products are subsidized so that the economy, as well as the society, can enjoy
positive externalities. According to Harris (2009) in a free market, it is
often noted that positive externalities are ignored regarding consumption, for
instance, using electric cars, people often fail to consider the reduction in
pollution their decision creates. Hence, a free market is characterized by the
ignorance of ‘external benefits’ derived from consumption of a certain good.
Subsidies lead to greater social efficiency due to consumers paying socially
efficient prices that are complemented by external benefits. For example, by
the Municipality of The Hague subsidizing public transport by offering
incentives for electric cars will encourage the residents to purchase electric
cars, therefore “reducing the negative externalities to the society such as
pollution” (Holzmann, 2012). In the long run, the subsidies on electric cars
will result in the residents of the Municipality of The Hague changing
preferences. However, the potential issue that might face the Municipality of
The Hague is that the cost of the subsidy must be met through taxation.
Consequently some taxation most notably income tax affect the incentive of
people to work.
2.0
Type of market failure to be addressed
The adoption of
electric cars subsidies will tackle the pertinent issue associated with the
environmental and natural resources. However, these incentives are often taken
for granted due to the "polluter should pay" principle. Thus,
economic theories aid in policy decision making that support the adoption of
subsidies reflecting on the relevance and the areas to be dealt with
adequately. It should be acknowledged that subsidies are more prevalent in
energy and technology policy, for instance as depicted by the Municipality of
The Hague.
Consequently, externalities are an example of market
failure addressed by subsidies (Lane et al., 2013). For example, if a cost or
benefit associated with consumption of an individual good, that is not borne by
an agent consuming that good, the obvious that cost or benefit is referred to
as an externality. Pollution is a
by-product of petrol powered vehicles thus it is a negative externality
associated with an external cost. As a result, the vehicle owners polluting the
environment do not suffer the consequences of their actions. Thus, the use of
electric cars is a positive externality connected to an external benefit; the
residents within the Municipality of The Hague who will drive electric will
provide benefits to other residents by reducing the levels of environmental
pollution.
Additionally,
subsidies can directly be utilized for both positive and negative externalities
(Graham et al., 2014). Positive externalities, for example, incorporation of
enhanced energy technology such as electric cars the subsidy will be levied per
unit of the externality. Nevertheless, negative externalities such as pollution
from petrol powered vehicles; the subsidy is typically collected regarding
abatement of the externality. Thus, if a common ground is attained, the abating
producers, for instance, the petrol powered vehicle owners will achieve the
same level of emissions with taxing each abated unit. In consequence, the
subsidies will be used to promote the adoption of electric cars in the
transport system. Hence, this subsidy will tackle the pollutants negative
externality and the positive externality associated with the use of electric
cars.
3.0
Sensibility in
implementation of electric car subsidy
The increase in demand and consequently the prices of petrol have led to the rise for calls for policy change to reduce the consumption of petrol, most notably in the transport sector by adopting electric cars. Thus, this has led environmental lobbyists to come up with more alternative fuel consumption mandates, with various governments under municipalities offering subsidies to purchase electrics cars. However, the economic reality of this subsidies are not yet at the original level, and the most immediate indicator will be when the financiers of the subsidies stop using taxpayers money to enhance consumption of electric cars. According to Koppelaar and Middlekoop (2017), affected governments should not provide additional taxpayer-funded subsidies for electric cars and should eradicate the policies already instituted. Thus, instead of the government under municipalities issuing out subsidies, the private...